Crash With an Out-of-State Driver in NJ: How Your Claim Works

New Jersey sits between New York and Pennsylvania, with I-95, I-80, I-78 and the Garden State Parkway carrying drivers from all over the country. So when a crash happens here, there's a good chance the other driver has out-of-state plates.

That can make a stressful situation more confusing. Which state's law applies? Whose insurance pays your medical bills? Do you have to go to New York or Pennsylvania to file a claim? The attorneys at Barreto Law Firm explain how a crash with an out-of-state driver works in New Jersey.

What Happens If an Out-of-State Driver Hits You in New Jersey?

If an out-of-state driver causes a crash in New Jersey, you can usually bring your claim in New Jersey, and New Jersey law generally governs who was at fault. If you have a New Jersey auto policy, your own PIP coverage pays your medical bills first, no matter who caused the crash. For pain and suffering and other losses, you make a claim against the at-fault driver's liability insurance, even if that policy was written in another state. Under New Jersey's Deemer Statute, many out-of-state policies are treated as carrying New Jersey's required coverage while the car is used here. If the other driver's coverage is too low, your own UM/UIM coverage may help. The two-year filing deadline still applies.

Key Takeaways

  • You can usually sue in New Jersey when the crash happened here, even if the other driver lives elsewhere.

  • New Jersey law generally decides fault for crashes on New Jersey roads.

  • Your own PIP pays first for your medical bills if you have a New Jersey policy.

  • The Deemer Statute applies New Jersey coverage rules to many out-of-state policies while the car is in New Jersey.

  • Other states' minimum limits may be low, which makes your UIM coverage important.

  • Rental and commercial vehicles follow special rules.

  • Most lawsuits must be filed within two years of the crash.

Which State's Law Applies to an Out-of-State Driver Accident?

For most crashes on New Jersey roads, New Jersey law decides who was at fault and how damages work. New Jersey courts use a "most significant relationship" test to choose the law that applies, adopted in P.V. v. Camp Jaycee (2008). When the crash, the injuries and the road rules are all in New Jersey, that test usually points to New Jersey law.

That means New Jersey rules like these generally apply:

  • Comparative fault (N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.1). You can recover as long as you're not more than 50% at fault, but your award is reduced by your share of fault.

  • New Jersey traffic laws, such as speed limits, right-of-way rules and the ban on handheld phones while driving.

  • The two-year statute of limitations for injury claims (N.J.S.A. 2A:14-2).

Some questions can be different. For example, if both drivers live in the same other state, or a vehicle owner's liability is at issue, another state's law may apply to that specific question. An attorney can sort out which law controls each issue in your case.

Can I Sue an Out-of-State Driver in New Jersey?

Yes. A driver who causes a crash on New Jersey roads can be sued in a New Jersey court, even if they live in another state.

New Jersey's Non-Resident Motorist Act (N.J.S.A. 39:7-2) makes this practical. By driving in New Jersey, a nonresident driver appoints the state's motor vehicle agency as their agent to receive lawsuit papers for crashes here. That means your attorney can serve the lawsuit through the state, with notice mailed to the driver, instead of tracking them down in person across state lines.

Filing in New Jersey has real benefits for injured New Jersey residents:

  • Your case stays close to home, near your doctors, witnesses and the crash scene.

  • The police report, the scene and local witnesses are all in New Jersey.

  • You don't need to hire a lawyer in another state for a crash that happened here.

Who Pays After a Crash With an Out-of-State Driver?

Several types of insurance can come into play. Understanding the order helps you know what to expect.

Your PIP Pays Your Medical Bills First

New Jersey is a no-fault state. If you have a New Jersey auto policy, your own Personal Injury Protection (PIP) pays your medical bills after a crash, no matter who caused it, and no matter where the other driver is from. Passengers and pedestrians may also be covered through the vehicle involved or a household policy.

Learn more in our post on how no-fault insurance really works after a crash.

The At-Fault Driver's Liability Insurance

For pain and suffering, losses beyond PIP and vehicle damage, you make a claim against the at-fault driver's bodily injury liability coverage, even if it's an out-of-state policy. Their insurer will handle the claim, often from an office in another state.

If you chose the limitation on lawsuit (verbal threshold) option on your New Jersey policy, you can sue for pain and suffering only if your injury meets one of the categories in N.J.S.A. 39:6A-8(a), such as a displaced fracture or a permanent injury. Your policy choice still matters when the other driver is from out of state. See our guide to New Jersey car insurance requirements and your right to sue.

What Is New Jersey's Deemer Statute?

The Deemer Statute (N.J.S.A. 17:28-1.4) applies to out-of-state auto policies written by insurers that are authorized to do business in New Jersey, or that are connected to an insurer that is. When a car covered by one of those policies is used or operated in New Jersey, the policy is deemed to include New Jersey's required coverage, including PIP.

The statute matters in a few ways:

  • The out-of-state driver gets New Jersey PIP benefits for their own injuries.

  • The out-of-state driver may also be bound by the lawsuit limitation when they try to sue for pain and suffering (Whitaker v. DeVilla, N.J. 1997).

  • Not every out-of-state insurer is covered. In Zabilowicz v. Kelsey (N.J. 2009), the New Jersey Supreme Court held that a defendant whose insurer wasn't authorized in New Jersey couldn't use the lawsuit limitation against the injured plaintiff.

Whether the Deemer Statute applies depends on the other driver's insurer, so it's one of the first things an attorney checks.

What If the Other Driver's Coverage Is Too Low?

Other states set their own minimum coverage. For example, Pennsylvania's minimum bodily injury limits are $15,000 per person and $30,000 per accident, and New York's are $25,000 and $50,000. Those amounts can run out quickly after a serious injury.

That's where your own coverage helps:

  • Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage can pay the difference when the at-fault driver's limits are too low to cover your losses.

  • Uninsured motorist (UM) coverage can pay when the other driver has no insurance at all or flees the scene.

Our post on PIP, BI and UIM coverage explains how these coverages work together.

What If the Out-of-State Driver Was in a Rental Car?

Tourists and business travelers often drive rental cars. Under a federal law called the Graves Amendment (49 U.S.C. § 30106), a rental company generally isn't liable just because it owns the car. The claim is usually against the driver and the driver's insurance, plus any coverage bought at the rental counter. The rental company may still be responsible if it was negligent itself, for example by renting out a car with a known defect.

What If It Was a Commercial Truck or Delivery Vehicle?

Many out-of-state vehicles on New Jersey highways are tractor-trailers and delivery trucks. Interstate trucking companies must carry much higher federal minimum insurance, generally at least $750,000 for general freight. These cases can involve the driver, the trucking company and others. Read who is liable in a New Jersey truck accident, or learn about our New Jersey truck accident lawyers. Crashes with Uber or Lyft drivers from other states follow rideshare insurance rules; see our rideshare accident lawyer page.

What to Do After a Crash With an Out-of-State Driver

An out-of-state driver may leave New Jersey within hours of the crash, so gathering information at the scene matters more than usual:

  • Call 911 and get a police report. The report records the driver's name, address, license state, plate number and insurance details. Learn more about New Jersey car accident reports.

  • Photograph the other driver's license, insurance card and plate, including the state.

  • Get the vehicle owner's name if it's different from the driver, such as a rental company or employer.

  • Take photos of the scene, the vehicles and your injuries.

  • Collect witness names and phone numbers. Witnesses may also be travelers who won't be easy to find later.

  • Get medical care right away, and tell your doctor the crash caused your symptoms.

  • Notify your own insurance company promptly to open your PIP claim.

Our NJ car accident checklist walks through everything to collect.

How Long Do You Have to File?

In New Jersey, most car accident injury lawsuits must be filed within two years of the crash. That deadline doesn't change because the other driver lives in another state. Claims involving a government vehicle require a written notice within 90 days. See our guide to the New Jersey statute of limitations for personal injury.

Common Mistakes After an Out-of-State Driver Accident

  • Letting the driver leave without exchanging information.

  • Assuming you have to file in the other driver's state. For a crash in New Jersey, you usually don't.

  • Giving a recorded statement to the other driver's out-of-state insurer before talking to a lawyer.

  • Accepting a quick offer limited by a low out-of-state policy without checking your own UIM coverage.

  • Waiting to open your PIP claim, which can delay payment for treatment.

  • Missing the two-year deadline while waiting for an out-of-state insurer to respond.

What If You're the Out-of-State Driver?

If you live in another state and were hurt in a crash in New Jersey, you may still bring a claim here. Your own insurer may provide New Jersey PIP benefits under the Deemer Statute, but that may also limit your right to sue for pain and suffering. The rules depend on your insurer and your policy, so get advice from a New Jersey attorney before you give statements or sign anything.

How Barreto Law Firm Helps

The attorneys at Barreto Law Firm handle car accident claims across New Jersey, including crashes with drivers from New York, Pennsylvania and beyond. Our New Jersey car accident lawyers can:

  • Identify every insurance policy, including out-of-state, rental and commercial coverage.

  • Check whether the Deemer Statute applies and how it affects your claim.

  • Deal with out-of-state insurers so you don't have to.

  • File and serve your lawsuit in New Jersey, if needed, through the Non-Resident Motorist Act.

  • Pursue UM/UIM benefits when the other driver's coverage falls short.

  • Help you in English or Spanish. Visit our Hablamos Español page.

Frequently Asked Questions About Out-of-State Driver Accidents in NJ

Can I sue an out-of-state driver in New Jersey?

Yes. If the crash happened in New Jersey, you can usually sue the out-of-state driver in a New Jersey court. Under the Non-Resident Motorist Act, N.J.S.A. 39:7-2, a nonresident who drives in New Jersey can be served with a lawsuit through the state's motor vehicle agency.

Which state's law applies if an out-of-state driver hits me in NJ?

New Jersey law generally applies to a crash on New Jersey roads, including its comparative fault rules and two-year statute of limitations. In some cases, another state's law may apply to a specific issue, such as a vehicle owner's liability.

Who pays my medical bills if an out-of-state driver hits me?

If you have a New Jersey auto policy, your own PIP coverage pays your medical bills first, regardless of who caused the crash or where the other driver lives. You can then make a claim against the at-fault driver's liability insurance for other losses.

What is the New Jersey Deemer Statute?

The Deemer Statute, N.J.S.A. 17:28-1.4, treats many out-of-state auto policies as including New Jersey's required coverage, such as PIP, while the car is used in New Jersey. It applies when the out-of-state insurer is authorized to do business in New Jersey or is connected to one that is.

What if the out-of-state driver's insurance limits are too low?

Other states may have lower minimum coverage. If the at-fault driver's limits don't cover your losses, your own underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage may pay the difference.

Do I have to go to the other driver's state to file a claim?

Usually not. For a crash in New Jersey, your claim and any lawsuit can generally be handled in New Jersey. The other driver's insurer may be based elsewhere, but your attorney can deal with it directly.

How long do I have to file a claim after a crash with an out-of-state driver?

Most New Jersey car accident injury lawsuits must be filed within two years of the crash. The deadline is the same even if the other driver lives in another state.

Hit by an Out-of-State Driver? Talk to Barreto Law Firm Today

A crash with an out-of-state driver can involve unfamiliar insurers, different state rules and a driver who has already gone home. You don't have to sort it out alone. The attorneys at Barreto Law Firm will review your case and explain your options.

Follow Barreto Law Firm on Instagram and Facebook for more New Jersey legal tips.

Disclaimer: This blog is for general information only and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case is different, so speak with a licensed New Jersey attorney about your situation.


Next
Next

Do I Need a Lawyer for a Municipal Court Ticket in NJ?